Managing by exception: a better way to lead employee growth
On Tuesday morning, Dana, a frontline nurse supervisor in a busy outpatient clinic, paused as she scanned her microlearning dashboard. One name stood out: Karen. The platform showed she had struggled with the new electronic records system introduced the previous week—her completion times were lagging, her confidence indicators were low, and she had stalled on the final module.
Dana also noticed that Alex had made excellent progress. He had already mastered all three competencies in the program, with consistently high confidence signals across each one. His accuracy was solid, his engagement levels were strong, and he had even volunteered to participate in an upcoming pilot module.
Dana considered her options. Should she spend a few minutes with Karen to reframe a concept? Should she assign her a worked example video for guided practice? Could Alex serve as a peer mentor to others on the team, helping normalize the new system?
As she made those quick decisions, Dana wasn't following a checklist or reacting to gut instinct—she was using a management model known as Management by Exception (MBE). Instead of checking in on every nurse equally, she focused her limited attention where it was needed most—on those falling behind and those ready to accelerate.
The hidden opportunity in every manager's role
Training and development are essential components of every manager's responsibilities—especially for those on the front lines. But in practice, they're often treated as peripheral tasks, sidelined by the pressures of daily operations.
In fact, according to a recent Gartner study, only 24% of frontline managers feel they are effective at developing their direct reports. Another report by McKinsey found that while 83% of executives say that frontline talent development is critical to performance, less than 30% say their organization does it well.
Why the disconnect? Most frontline managers are time-starved, metrics-driven, and expected to lead teams while juggling operations, customer demands, and reporting. The idea of actively coaching each employee's development quickly becomes unrealistic—unless there's a system to focus that effort where it counts.
That's where MBE comes in.
What is management by exception?
Management by Exception is a classic management principle that originated in the mid-20th century, particularly within manufacturing and finance. The core idea is simple: don't waste time overseeing routine performance—focus only on deviations from the norm.
Instead of blanket supervision, MBE channels attention to the outliers: where something is going unusually well or unusually poorly. In the context of employee development, this means managers focus their time and energy on the people who either need support to regain traction or are ready to be stretched further.
MBE can be thought of as the opposite of micromanagement. And when it comes to employee development, micromanagement is especially dangerous. It disempowers learners, undermines confidence, and adds friction to learning instead of removing it. The goal is not to control every learning step—it's to know when to step in and why.
Defining the right KPIs
For MBE to work in employee development, organizations need to define the right performance signals—the kinds of KPIs that help managers know when to intervene, and with whom.
These KPIs fall into two broad categories: inertia indicators (who's stuck) and momentum indicators (who's ready to grow). Both are critical to helping frontline managers make effective development decisions.
Inertia KPIs: Who Needs a Nudge
Inertia KPIs highlight learners who are stalling, struggling, or disengaged. They help managers identify early signs of friction, such as:
- Module abandonment: learners who start but don't finish training sequences.
- Low confidence signals: self-assessments that trend downward or voice/text patterns that suggest hesitation.
- Long completion times: falling significantly behind their peers in finishing training modules.
- Repeated failure points: missteps on the same concept despite multiple attempts.
These indicators surface where friction exists in the learning journey—so managers can respond with just-in-time support, coaching, or tailored reinforcement.
Momentum KPIs: Who's Ready to Be Stretched
MBE is often misunderstood as a tool for addressing problems only. In reality, it's just as powerful for identifying and supporting positive exceptions—employees who are excelling and ready for more.
Momentum KPIs reveal learners who are gaining traction and can be leveraged as early leaders or peer coaches. These include:
- High-confidence mastery: fast, accurate, and confident performance across multiple competencies.
- Proactive engagement: volunteering for stretch tasks, submitting extra practice, or requesting feedback.
- Upward trajectory: consistent improvement in both competence and confidence metrics over time.
- Peer recognition: positive reviews or requests from colleagues for support or insight.
By surfacing these high performers, MBE allows managers to reinforce what's working and scale those successes across the team—often by enlisting these learners to help their peers.
Why MBE belongs in every frontline manager's toolkit
For managers like Dana, MBE powered by AI microlearning platforms like Surge9 becomes a powerful tool to make employee development practical and focused.
Instead of guessing who needs help, Dana gets a real-time view into each learner's performance and mindset. Instead of managing everyone equally, she allocates attention precisely. Instead of micromanaging learning, she steps in only when her support can have the greatest impact.
In short, MBE turns development from a vague obligation into a targeted management strategy—one that respects the manager's time, the learner's autonomy, and the organization's goals.
And when applied to training, it gives every employee the right push, at the right time, from a manager who is finally empowered to lead development with clarity and confidence.
Turn managers into strategic coaches
Discover how Surge9's AI-powered platform helps frontline managers focus their time where it matters most.